I missed it when she first posted it, but wayyyy back in May, Smartygirl commented on the following statements by Michael Brossard, senior vice-president of marketing and development at Rona, the Quebec-based home improvement chain:
…women are becoming more involved in purchasing decisions. But even as Rona reaches out to them, Mr. Brossard says he sees no need to stock female-friendly power tools. “In general, they’re not doing the heavy work,” he said.
“Tools is still the toy section for guys. Will it become the toy section for girls? I don’t think so.”
Despite the statistics on women buying and renovating homes, Mr. Brossard said, “A single woman will have a dad, a boyfriend, an uncle to help them. It’s not as though they’re totally alone.”
I wont go into detail ripping this apart because Ms. Smart already did a good job of it. A few of comments of hers that resonated with me:
-
I have been known to let my husband borrow my tools, although after the way he messed up my chisel, that happens less frequently.
-
The only difficulty I have ever had with any project is not weakness, or feminine incompetence, it is good old procrastination, which I know for a fact affects men as much as women.
-
My husband does offer to help with heavy lifting, but he knows that if I’m working on a project he’d best just get out of my way, as having people underfoot just makes me cranky.
I think the scenarios she describes are far more common than popular mythology would have us believe, and certainly more-so than Mr. Promoted-to-the-least-of-his-abilities Marketing Guy realizes.
Projects go down in my house much the way they do in Smarty’s, The Rapper having admitted that prior to our recent painting escapades, the largest home improvement he had ever attempted was to mow one lawn once. The tools are mine. The barbecue is mine. The remote controls are still mainly his, but come on, people, get with reality.
As for the issue of woman-friendly power tools, Smarty doesn’t feel she needs them. She can lift anything anyway. What I’m not sure she or Yo Marketing Dumbass realize is that the concept of woman-friendly power tools isn’t just that they’re lighter or that they come pink or something, although weight is part of it. The idea is that they can be operated easily with smaller hands, or that their balance is calibrated so they work better with the ratios and proportions of a woman’s body (much like women’s shoes need to support the actual proportions of a woman’s feet, which are different from those of a man), so the woman isn’t working against the tool. Essentially: that a power tool is supposed to do more of the work for you. Using one shouldn’t be a question of strength or force in the first place. In something like a drill, this isn’t a big deal, but when it comes to, say, chainsaws or heavy industrial equipment, it can play a serious role in injury prevention. It’s a question of physiology, not ability or aptitude.



Comments
Comment from andrew
Time: August 28, 2007, 2:14 pm
Seems like that dude is shooting hisself in the foot - isn’t he all about attracting people to Rona’s products in order to sell more things that they may make more money? But if he is saying that they will not carry products designed for 52% of the population, that an increasing amount of that market is becoming interested in due to HGTV and the realities of home-owning in urban/suburban/exurban markets, isn’t he basically saying they can afford to ignore a new revenue stream, one that is showing all signs of growing? Why would a corporation as large as Rona continue to employ someone who is basically saying they don’t want to make more money? Or lose money to their competitors?
These are the questions people should ask. And they should definitely not ask me to fix anything, ever. I’m a little more experienced than the Rapper but barely.
Comment from Jill
Time: August 28, 2007, 7:46 pm
Exaaactly.
On a related note, I was standing outside Rivoli in Toronto the other night, and DJ Mensa needed a pen, and my only pen was in my Swiss Army Thing that’s pretty small, but has pliers and a complete screwdriver set with interchangeable bits, and he picks the thing up and says to me: “Dude! You’ve got more tools in your purse than I have in my whole apartment!”
So… so far 3/3 DJs have a better grip on marketing tools to women than this dude whose job it is. And I bet he can’t mix either.
Comment from andrew
Time: August 29, 2007, 1:20 pm
You know he’d be one of those DJ’s, though, who would say things like “Women’s eardrums are smaller so they can’t hear the music as well as men, so they can’t DJ”. And he’d also probably play either bad Southern rap or trance.
Comment from Jill
Time: August 29, 2007, 1:38 pm
Close, Andrew, close. But I think you may be overlooking the obvious:
Wedding DJ!
Comment from andrew
Time: August 30, 2007, 10:28 am
Hey, as a card-carrying member of the International Association of Wedding Disc Jockeys, I take umbrage. And also, requests.
Comment from Jill
Time: August 30, 2007, 10:34 am
Ha!
I think we have just crossed that threshold where your comments on this blog have become more entertaining than the blog itself.
How meta!
Comment from andrew
Time: August 30, 2007, 2:06 pm
Yes! But I think you do your wit a disservice. You cause honest-to-goodness laugh out loud moments at my cubicle. The Justice Sector’s Work/Life Balance HR Reps owe you lunch, lady.
Write a comment